Sunday, April 28, 2013

Story Lines

Doctors are trying to rationalize our current story line:  the loss of autonomy and pay cuts are a necessary evil for the greater good.   We're taking one for the excess-health care cost team.  We're willing to take this personal sacrifice for our fellow man and woman.   It is the noble thing to do.   It will be good for America's healthcare system if we do our part, work harder to improve inefficiencies.   There are even doctors in leadership positions who reflect in their three-year "honest assessment" of our current health care law that higher taxes and near-30% rise in insurance premiums are a necessary evil for extending insurance to 30 million more Americans.  "I am glad to do my part," they comment.  How could anyone argue with such beneficence?

Doctors who sacrifice and give tirelessly to their patients are our storybook ideal; what every American loves to envision.  But we should also acknowledge that there is another story line: that many physicians are deeply concerned with the realities of what's taking place in health care lately.

Doctors are witnessing health care costs greatly outstripping inflation, especially since our new health care law was put in place.
  • People aren't using their coverage because they fear the cost of their much higher deductibles.

  • Insurance companies have created their own convenient loophole to avoid the consequences of their own new law.

  • With the initial deployment of the law only eight short months away, the promised insurance "exchanges" have yet to be fully deployed nor explained to the public.

  • The small business health care program has been delayed.

  • People with pre-existing conditions stopped being covered in February, 2013  because the government agency responsible for this portion of the law ran out of funds.
  • More concerning for those who are budget-minded, as of today, not a single member of the the law's Independent Payment Advisory Board, the 15-member panel that is supposed to recommend cuts to the Medicare program beginning 1 January 2014 to maintain its solvency, has been selected, much less approved.
Meanwhile, our nation's leadership is enjoying the black-tie White House Correspondent's Dinner in appreciation of those who serve as our Great Distributor of Washington story lines, aptly named "Nerd Prom."

Perhaps I shouldn't be so harsh.  After all, it was just in the spirit of poking fun.  I should also accept that since American Medicine is our largest employer and nation's largest business, American Medicine will forever be tainted by politics.  But as we have seen time and time again, it is common in politics to sell Story A when, in fact, the real motivation for something is Story B. When political initiatives are deployed that are uncomfortable there has to be something that people will emphatically rally behind.  How else could we send our children off to war, for instance?

And so it has been with health care.

Story A was that this whole health care story line was about the uninsured.

Yet people were never waving flags and demonstrating in the streets for wellness initiatives with free mammograms, physicals and flu shots.  People were not looking for more and more middle layers of bureaucracy, red tape, and management.   People are not demanding that first-year medical residents see patients for only 12% of their day because of training rules. People were not looking for their doctor to become a nursing supervisor, medical coder or typist.    People were not picketing the Supreme Court for double-digit insurance company stock market returns so they could enjoy higher premiums and deductibles.    People were not hoping for $100-million golden parachutes for pharmaceutical executives. People were not lobbying for bigger hospitals competing with other hospitals for wealthy patients, each filled with outdated computers, waterfallsbig screen TVs and kiosks in "anticipation" of what was to come.   And people were REALLY not expecting the government to burn through their cash so fast that they'd be asking for more money so soon.  

Yet here we all are, realizing our new, disturbing story line.

Doctors, patients, ...

... and Nerd Prom.



Anonymous said...

I've heard from friends looking to change jobs that they've been offered 30 or 31 hours of work - not 36-40.

The job is described as full time during the interview, and then almost imperceptibly mentioned, that it's only 30 hours...

Employers avoiding insuring.


Andrew_M_Garland said...

Stories about $5 doctors and other heroes of the new social-justice society fit into the plans of socialists and totalitarians. As productivity drops and people are not paid, there must be myths about the minimal costs of great medical care.

Cuba is exalted as the land of great medical care for everyone. In fact, it has a two-tier system. Great care for the top 10%, and lousy, make-believe care for the rest.

Russia's dictators have always exalted the dedicated, low-paid worker who devotes himself to his country and not to his own selfish desires

Putin Revives Stalinist Cult of the Worker Hero
=== ===
[edited] The cult of the industrious worker reached its peak in Stalin's era. Its revival under Putin will bring back horrific memories of slave-labour working conditions and frequent punishments for alleged misdemeanours that often led to a spell in the gulag. Stalin told his people that they must imitate Stakhanov, a miner who dug more coal in a day than anyone else.
=== ===

These worker stories are always needed to explain away what people see with their eyes. They see lines, poor quality, poor supply, and rationing. These stories suggest that we would all be better off if they merely worked as hard as those Cuban doctors, Stakhanov, and the $5 doctor. Don't be selfish with your skills, and proudly serve the common man under the wise state.